# famulus-objection/1 — an objection to an issue of Famulus Expertise No issue is beyond error (rule R10 of the series). An objection names the point of an issue it contradicts and gives its grounds. It is recorded, examined by the same standard as the issue (references resolve, a quoted wording stands at its place, the argument is examined in Famulus Lektor at the point concerned) and kept with its outcome. The author of the issue classifies it; an objection that convinces is annotated at the point concerned in a new version of the issue, in the text, in the preamble (`critique`) and in the answers of the MCP server (`fx_objections`; `fx_claims` marks the claim `contested`). An objection that does not convince stays on record with the reason. An objection is a YAML or JSON document; a person or an agent can write it. It is sent to the address the issue names (`objections_to`); a public tool for filing follows when the MCP server of the series is public. ```yaml schema: famulus-objection/1 issue: fr:expertise/euler/1 # the issue version: "1.0" # the version the objection reads point: # what is contradicted: exactly one of claim: C3 # a claim of the preamble (claims[].id) # thesis: "" # a thesis or assumption, quoted from the issue # section: sec-results # a section of the issue statement: "" grounds: # at least one - ref: fr:enestroem/E57/0018/p03 # a Famulus reference, or note: "" - citation: "" - argument: "" by: name: "" kind: person # person | agent contact: "" date: 2026-11-12 ``` Fields the register adds (`publication/famulus-lettre/objections/-.yaml`): `id` (O1, O2, … per issue), `received`, `status` (`received | under-examination | convincing | not-convincing | withdrawn`), `examination` (what was checked, with the result), `decision {by, on, reason}` (the author's; no program decides), and for a convincing objection `annotation {text, since_version}`.